ManMachine
@max@manmachine.me
someone in the comments of my no AI notice is very butthurt lol
big "i am very angry and wish to speak to the manager of people not liking AI" energy on this one
@eniko it's like going to a market and start complaining to a hand-made art piece salesperson that amazon exists
@eniko "You indie developer who shipped actual indie games without - and even before! - the advent of genAI should absolutely listen to my uninformed hot take on the topic, or else!"
i love the "but you don't understand, i *have* to use AI otherwise it's too hard for me" argument
literal definition of skill issue my guy
@eniko I had one neat game idea, but it required a lot of artwork that would have been infeasible; ai use would have enabled it. Community reaction - just the mention of ai use - killed the project. Whether that's a good or a bad thing depends.
@eniko Indie game development's a pretty risky venture no matter how you slice it... lots of solid games have been made that never get anywhere near profitable for various reasons, often in spite of quite high quality work... so I'm not sure why folks seem to believe that using the slop machine is going to improve their odds of standing out and succeeding... seems to me the opposite is far more likely.
@eniko i fully agree with you about AI but even before that anyone who wields the argument about the utility cost of not using your personal time making money in other business has the soul of a landlord
@eniko ai... Don't understand? The "no ai" notice doesn't change anything for them when they use ai, does it??
@leberschnitzel they're mad that people don't like AI to the point someone would make something like this and it would then become popular
@eniko No, see, you don't understand: they're just a smol bean and that means nobody's allowed to criticise their choices even implicitly.
@eniko This person clearly had no interest in making indie games until he thought he could shit one out on the cheap and rake in apparently millions of dollars (how else would those multi-million dollar indie games be profitable?). Dude's in for a rude awakening when he finds out what the industry is like.
1. Where are those super high quality cheaply made AI games?
2. It’s a socioeconomic issue, if I was independently wealthy or we all had a living UBI I wouldn’t care much, human made things would still exist and people can live.
3. What about flooding the market? If I can make a game for let’s say $5000 in token cost, and 5,000 other people made that same game right after me. Can I even make that $5000 back?
Plus artistic and environmental arguments etc. The “I don’t care” above doesn’t include the environment nor the market effects (RAM prices etc) and such.
Sometimes it feels like arguing about social Darwinism with people when it comes to AI:/
@eniko So this person's response to "indie games require a lot of investment from a person to be done" is "burn money in the slop machine".
what?
@eniko It's such a mild expression of anti-AI sentiment, too. Like, it's just saying that your specific project didn't use AI. Why are they so threatened by that?
@BathysphereHat because I made it, and it's popular, which means people hate AI, which means their AI slop won't be well received. And not only that but I'm actively trying to poison the well for AI by showing that hating AI isn't just acceptable, it's good actually
@eniko
If an indie game costs $10,000 or more to make, you're either using wrong tools, or you're using that money to pay for marketing. Every single aspect of an indie game can be made 100% free, with free tools (provided access to computer exists). Sure, if you wanna pay artists who do an aspect better than you, it costs, but I rather listen to PC-beeper churning out random notes on EGA palette of ASCII characters on a game that has no text, than wanna see any AI in any aspect of the process.
What is your favorite buldak ramen flavor?
| carbonara: | 0 |
| chicken: | 0 |
| 2x spicey: | 1 |
| cheese: | 0 |
| habanero lime: | 0 |
| curry: | 0 |
| other: | 0 |
| other ramen only: | 0 |
| not a ramen person: | 0 |
we've created a no AI notice that we'll be using to reassure people seeing our trailers and games, with hand drawn lettering and a relaxing cute sleepy fox, and it's also up on itch in multiple formats for anyone to use: https://eniko.itch.io/cute-fox-no-ai-notice
options include with/without fox, opaque/transparent, and 4k, 2160p, 1440p, 1080p, and 720p resolutions
it's also incredibly funny to upload this the day anthropic files their IPO. get fucked, anthropic
Kris D. (they/them) of the Pnictogen Wing [They/Them] » 🌐
@kris_of_pnictogen@mastodon.octofriends.garden
@eniko wouldn't Made by Organic Beings or Made by Creatures be more inclusive
@eniko 2160p is 4K though?
@thesupertechie i have been told by wikipedia that true 4k tends to be wider than 16:9 and the 16:9 version of 4k is often colloquially referred to as 2160p to distinguish between the two
@eniko None means none... anywhere in the production pipeline, right ?
@ZoidbergForPresident not sure what you're asking
@eniko "No AI" means no ai, not in the finished product and not anywhere else before in the production pipeline. So using aigen for preparatory sketches or whatnot IS using aigen.
@eniko is it alright to edit the text to "made by a human"? I'm a lonely creator. I'll keep the typography right I promise
i'll do another proper announcement post later around primetime but the no AI notice with cute fox is up on itch now: https://eniko.itch.io/cute-fox-no-ai-notice
kinda absurd creative commons doesn't have a no AI license yet
@eniko I imagine it's quite tricky to come up with a robust legal definition of ai, especially when nobody can agree on even a mundane definition.
@eniko@mastodon.gamedev.place they seem to be more interested in being ai shills anyway like check their blog
@eniko they wrote on their blog that they believe that’s not a thing because in their view, using media to train AI is fair use, i.e. always permitted even in the absence of a license, and they think this is a good thing.
@scott well i guess it's easy enough to add to my licenses as an additional condition ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@eniko there is no legal precedent on whether you even *need* a license to allow AI training in most places so, yeah, sticking some phrase onto your license is easy but if that phrase actually has any effect is something even the best lawyers are gonna have difficulties definitively answering
@eniko aren't all of CC (except CC0) no-ai by default? since they all require attribution and no LLM can really do that by design.
@eniko I love it, and will use it in future.
Unfortunately for my current project it would arguably be a lie, since I likely got some subconscious help from Google's AI before I blocked it
Great art! though you might throw all of the pngs through a PNG optimizer, I was able to get plain-no-ai-notice-opaque.png down 23% 302kb -> 232kb with a bit of effort, if you'd like I can do it for ya and send you a zip with the re-compressed pngs :3
(I say this as a compression obsessed dev, though ironically I've never implemented compression algorithims)
@mathium05 i think the pngs are small enough as is >_> if someone wants to have them more optimized they can do that on their end i think
Ps ps ps
I like the diversity of the comments
@nina_kali_nina My precius! No! It's Bad! made me do bad things... Everything can be talked, let's sit, EXterminate!!!!! Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent.
@nina_kali_nina error: process ID list syntax error
Usage:
ps [options]
Try 'ps --help <simple|list|output|threads|misc|all>'
or 'ps --help <s|l|o|t|m|a>'
for additional help text.
For more details see ps(1).
@nina_kali_nina mew? I'll see if any pawed acquaintance wishes to add something, they'll probably throw in a bit of mew mew, miau and some purring.
Or maybe I'll strategically position a keyboard and see if they want to type Postscript code.
ended up doing some maintenance on one of my webservers. realised it's actually got a whole bunch of virtual hosts, but all of them were pulled from dns a long long time ago.
so... just one domain live now.
i thought this would be simple, in that "it's only serving a directory listing"
but actually it was serving...
a directory listing in the root
a whole bunch of custom HEADER.htmls for some of them
and a lot of load-bearing .htaccess which nginx won't respect.
hardcoded it for now. it's good enough. i just wanted a more debianistic way of keeping this crap online. i don't really have much energy for computer-touching like this anymore.
if it wasn't for the fact that the server is also one of my prod dns servers in a cluster that i'm still... sort of interested in keeping alive i might actually just kill it off.
archive.org has all of the rare loot, the other loot isn't so rare. idk. else i could shift it to any old hosting provider, since it's really not all that complex...
@0x47df if a shell/hosting account on a shared server would ever make your life easier just DM me, happy to useradd you.
Rule #1 of Cybersecurity:
Make sure the safety is off
@kallisti sometimes i cringe when i see these old pictures. i can't believe the first time i ever drew mister mobilek, i shot him.
and now everyone loves him..
Philomena: Some people have been writing PHP for over 20 years. Is that because it's particularly difficult to finish?
Expert: No, software is constantly evolving.
Philomena: So they've been writing the same website for 20 years?
Expert: No, different projects.
Philomena: Have they tried finishing one before starting another?
Expert: That's not how software development works.
Philomena: My mate Paul spent 20 years building a shed. Turned out he was just an alcoholic.
Expert: Right.
Philomena: Is PHP like that?
Computers were not a mistake.
The Internet was not a mistake.
The mistake was allowing everything to be about money and power rather than community building.
As I keep reading over the PHP patches I keep seeing the devastation not of people who don't know how to write secure software, but decades of people with very little resources tasked with writing the most widely used internet-facing software on earth in the programming language I am a participant in shaping. I see that the slow pace of adoption of things that we were told would help people 20, 30 years ago by security experts has not been adopted, and some of the world's most complex codebases using things as fragile as setjmp/longjmp and abort for error handling.
I see, simply, that we are failing our software engineers by not having better in-language tools to mitigate and manage this level of complexity. That the pride in hacks we wore as a symbol of the power of C were in fact cries for help from a userbase that did not understand the long tail of consequences.
Good luck and God Bless to the system administrators today and tomorrow and for the rest of this month. I'll do my best to make it so C isn't like this, anymore.
poll for programmers only
are you a game developer or not? do you like AI for coding?
| coder & gamedev, dislike AI: | 618 |
| coder & gamedev, like AI: | 55 |
| non-gamedev coder, dislike AI: | 1330 |
| non-gamedev coder, like AI: | 125 |
Closed
@eniko If I'm a non-gamedev coder at work, but a gamedev coder as a hobby, which one do I choose?
@eniko I personally hate AI as a buzzword because corporations leverage their semantical right to encompass all good and bad apples.
That being said, I hate the abuse of GenAI and the overall tendency to steal people's crafts directly. My usage of LLMs is restricted to help understanding the language more than the code, and even in the worst case scenario I ask the LLM in case I let it code some stuff to help me understand the code and avoid lazy conventions (like labelling loop variables as "I, j and k" instead of something more descriptive).
People, especially non-english speakers, tend to forget that one of the reasons why we learn English is because programming languages such as Kotlin and C# work with reserved keywords that are meant to be analogous to real-world concepts.
In fact, one of the reasons why I feel people want to lean into LLMs for their coding work is the perception that code is too complicated to read, precisely because it tends to be coded with too many tricks for usually little performance gain and the bragging rights of having less lines or characters of code.
I know this because of this little talk I personally cherish: https://master.dev/teachers/kyle-simpson/code-is-for-humans/&sa=U&ved=2ahUKEwjLq_yU3c2XAxUcr5UCHbF2NwwQFnoECB0QAQ&usg=AOvVaw38GYefRUh1ZF40lGlPTDzr
To clarify my "non-gamedev, like AI" stance.
AI code assist bots like github copilot are a tool, nothing more. In my case it saves me time; time from crawling stack overflow to figure out how to do the thing I already know I want to do but perhaps in a language or framework Im unfamilliar with. But ultimately I'm still responsible for every line I commit, so Ill review every one to make sure I understand it.
Guess this puts me in the Torvalds camp of "they're tools; rejecting tools is dumb; be responsible for your proper use". The devs that vibe code a 14k line PR i treat with the same derision - there's NO way you could possible grok a change that big, its clear you're just promoting whatever the bot gave you.
Likewise, "adding" AI assist to products that don't need it is a completely different thing. Im in the "my email client doesn't need an AI assist to help me write emails thank you." camp.
Retired business application programmer here. Having worked directly with users, I relish the thought of them getting what they ask for instead of what they need.
Still dread what LLMs are doing to this planet.
@eniko The results so far are not surprising, but I expect a high selection bias from your followers. So while I'd love to conclude that most programmers dislike AI, I don't think that conclusion is valid.
It can still be true though. :-)
@eniko
Non-gamedev coder in Unity, that hates LLMs.
It really feels like discovering so many people you used to respect/work with never liked programming to begin with and just wanted to get money fast. Turns out I was the only one who every once in a month have intrusive thoughts to rewrite everything in Haskell.
Also feels like we as customers have been really trained for years to accept slop without protesting, so when LLMs happened nobody is complaining.
@eniko Non-gamedev coder, [who will start doing gamedev projects soon], hates AI with the power of a thousand suns.
@eniko non-gamedev with ambivalent stance, I both like ai and hate ai
@eniko for your next poll can you add an option: "I am not the target audience but I like responding to polls" 😂
@eniko I love any tool that works. Purpose-built neural nets have potential to be very useful tools..not unlike cold fusion.
@eniko not me spending five minutes wrestling with impostor syndrome before caling myself a game dev
(i have literally made at least one game, however small, that at least one other person has played. that's more than enough)
@eniko Despise AI and hate how previous workplaces have shoved it down my throat and in one case kicked me out for daring to point out flaws with it.
Hate even more that as I look for work I feel tempted to give in and at least lie about wanting to work with it. If I can find a place where I can be honest and shoot that shit down, that'd be great. Fullstack in southern Sweden btw if anyone knows a place, the job board and consulting market is grooooosss.
@eniko thanks for your support already, wow that was fast. Feels relieving to vent and get support rather than ai bros telling me I'll be left behind ❤️
@eniko I hate the greed, the insincerity, the scam-iness, the idiotic hype, and the business models around....
...well, just like with most industries these days, I guess.
@eniko
I am making a game but don't code so I hire a friend who codes and hates AI as much as I do. I will never give a cent of my tiny earnings to a single slop coder simp. <3
@eniko literally got turned down for a job because I expressed my distaste for AI in any form in the workplace. 😮💨
@eniko "I love AI" mumbles the half asleep non-gamedev next to me. I think it's sarcastic, but who knows.
@eniko Aaa I misread the options and accidentally voted wrong, TIL you can't withdraw or change your vote after voting on Mastodon
Our planet boiled last summer.
Why are we fucking around?
Everyone is gonna burn
We'll all take turns
I'll get mine too
This AI's gone to heaven.
@eniko oh wow Mastodon really is quite the bubble. While i dislike AI i seem to be in the minority position at work
@eniko i'm not surprised. only two cloud companies offer effortless workflows and depending on them is "false self-employment": when they go down, you go down.
then there are various AI hosters, including hetzner, but their prices cannot compete with those heavily subsidized disruptors.
running agents at home is constrained by RAM and compute capacity, but methodologies are sharpening. you have to do more yourself but it looks like the healthiest target to me right now.
@eniko Both and I dislike it. I have to use it extensively on my job and I don't mind it that much as "it's a job". But I don't use it at all at gamedev.
@eniko I feel like making this pool on fedi would result in pretty biased (but not far reality) results
@eniko I am forced to use AI at work, and as far as I can tell it speeds up the process for real. Also all the things about AI slop, technical debt etc. can be highly mitigated by preparing good quality code as context and using it for specific modules and components rather than trying to create a whole feature with it blindly.
The trade-off is burning the planet under data centers and that's not worth it at all. For my personal project I use EurIA sometimes.
@eniko
I experimented with early generative AI way before the hype and was really excited about it. And I'm still somewhat positive about the technology, but those feelings are vastly overshadowed by the damage it does nowadays: to the planet, to the economy, to artists and writers it steals from, to our brains, to the internet. I despise the reality of “AI” as it exists today. I partly blame it for killing my joy of creating video games.
@eniko I am very impressed by AI code generation, it helps me finish multiple side projects. But it depressed me as I nearly write no code now, and I enjoyed that very much.
“It’s a poor worksman who blames his tools” has always been complete nonsense. No-one complains about imperfect tools faster and louder than a master. A master will yank a cheap or damaged tool out of your hand and yell at you for not blaming it yet
Cheap, lousy tools come from middle managers who don’t know how to do your job. Blame the hell out of poor tools and those who demand you use them
@0xabad1dea But for the master craftsman that conversation is in the distant past.
It's taken me a long time to understand that the phrase "it's a poor craftsman who blames his tools" is not a simple sentence, but that it speaks to an understanding that a skilled craftsman chooses the best tools they can carefully, takes proper care of them, and takes responsibility for what those tools deliver.
@0xabad1dea It made sense back when a lot of craftsman were expected to make their own tools, so the quality of the tool was a reflection on the craftsman.
Today, yeah, a lot less sense
@0xabad1dea I'm with you!
The literal phrase means that a poor craftsperson blames their tools *for the craftperson's poor results.* The saying doesn't mean don't complain about tools, it means a craftsperson is accountable for the outcome and therefore takes responsibility for choosing and/or replacing their tools and using them well.
@0xabad1dea I understand that saying as finding excuse for shody work. A master will probably not make shody work so they have no reason to blame their well maintened tools
@0xabad1dea Yeah, whenever I hear someone say that, I always add: it's a poor worksman who blames his tools, because a good worksman knows how to choose his tools. So if he blames his tools, he blames himself.
But if the tools are forced upon you, well, then you're blaming your manager. Rightfully so.
@0xabad1dea I always saw it as "The poor workman will deliver poor work and blame it on the tools, a good workman will just get better tools"
@0xabad1dea Worse: managers and fellow workers - especially in #Capitalism systems where there's no such thing as 'too much' - are empowered to know which tools are faulty, and which are not, and keep you uninformed so they can have a more direct path to usurping your value, for their own.
#AbuseOfPower at scale
@0xabad1dea a lesson I learned a while ago is that if you are rummaging in the tool chest for "the good screwdriver" then you should probably buy another quality one and throw out all the bad ones.
@0xabad1dea well, if they weren't poor, they could buy better tools instead of complaining, so it's kinda makes sense 
When you reach the point that your tools restrict you more than your (lack of) skill, it’s time to get better tools. Knowing which situation you’re in is why we need teachers/mentors to guide us.
@0xabad1dea I think this might be more true today than long time ago. And likely for the same reason also: For the master would have seen the tools are not good and sharpened them first. There might be more depth to this phrase than is immediately apparent. 🤔
@0xabad1dea I think you're misunderstanding what the word blame means. and your example, the master Craftsman isn't blaming anything. they are correcting a problem. The poor craftsman doesn't correct the problem, they blame it afterwards.
@0xabad1dea A related fallacy is that cheap, poorly made tools are fine for novices, and that only experienced pros need the good stuff.
If I don't have experience with some task, and have no idea what I'm doing, I need all the help I can get. The last thing I need is introducing an "are my tools misbehaving?" variable. A pro would at least have a chance of knowing how to compensate.
@0xabad1dea The best tools make learning the best technique easy; they are transparent to the practitioner's skill. Bad tools are an opaque filter to the practitioner's skill. They make it hard for a novice to learn good technique, and leave inexperienced practitioners blaming themselves for the tool's poor results.
I have worked hard to make sure that anyone learning to play guitar gets to learn on a good guitar. There is nothing more detrimental and discouraging than trying to learn to play guitar on a piece of garbage.
@0xabad1dea I can see from reading the comments that lots of people spend a lot of time thinking about this stuff, which is good because it's important.
My own two cents is that it's about being the type of person that makes excuses vs the type of person that gets shit done.
Cause whatever it is that's limiting you, you get to choose between treating it as a problem to solve or as a pass to under-deliver time and time again.
@0xabad1dea I've internalized the not blaming your tools idea within my academic work. I don't blame the tools (students). I am not responsible for how they are when they enter my program, I am responsible for them when they exit.
@0xabad1dea It is a poor workman who blames his tools because the master doesn't have any crappy tools left.
@0xabad1dea JFYI: “to blame” and “to complain” are not synonyms. They have different meaning. As a result, they are not interchangeable.
@mudasobwa wow, I'm so glad that men I don't know are here to explain what "words" are to me, I'm a just silly little girl who doesn't understand my own post and not a fucking engineer making a point about fucking engineering
@0xabad1dea critically, it's a poor workman who blames his tools *and still keeps using them despite adequate opportunity to acquire better tools*
@0xabad1dea You still didn't get the extra RAM for the remote desktop system then?
If I recall correctly, that was you/your company... Could be wrong though!
@greem hahahahahahahahahahaha *sob*
@0xabad1dea I once tried learning to play the saxophone, on a malfunctioning saxophone. It was frustrating flailing about experience, and I only succeeded after it got repaired.
@0xabad1dea IMO the saying makes sense under the assumption the worksman's tools are actually fine (implying the worksman doesn't know how to use them)
But plenty including yourself have already mentioned how this statement immediately falls apart when that assumption is false 🤣
Like when a harbor freight C clip tool I had bent before it released the clip... 🤣🤣🤣
@0xabad1dea in my case, my manager does know how to do my job, but only with the lousy tools he used to do it with, so that's what I'm being trained on and it's my fault if I do it wrong.
@0xabad1dea Is this about the PHP? ;-) Anyways, I remember when a "head of engineering" pushed DynamoDB no matter what. It ended costing the company millions on retarded development (in all meanings of that word) and, later, on exploding usage fees. And, then, never-ending migration.
@0xabad1dea Reminds me of the adage that to attract and retain skilled people you need to provide ”sharp tools and interesting problems”.
@0xabad1dea I think the meaning is a good worksman is his own boss and knows what tool is good and bad, doing a bad job and blaming the tools as a way out of accountability, not that tool quality isnt a factor. Of course, everyone has a boss now and that boss has misaligned incentives.
@0xabad1dea Good lord, the literalism of some of the replies to this . . . A saying is understood by how it's used, not by quibbling about the vocabulary. (And I'm saying this as a quibbler.)
You're absolutely right—the saying, as generally understood by those using it, is simply wrong.
@0xabad1dea I think you eill find that the saying comes from a period when an apprentice had to make his own set of tools as part of his training.
A master craftsman does not make his finest crafts by haphazardly bashing them together with twigs.
He uses a hammer.
I've used a great many programming languages, IDEs, and other programming tools in my 30 years, and I definitely have opinions and preferences about which of them are best and why.
@0xabad1dea I've had a lot of music teachers tell me "well, that might be ok today, but you should get a better guitar when you can"
I've never yet had one tell me "that's too much guitar for you"
@0xabad1dea Most of the times that I've heard that lately, the statement is coming from someone who sold the crappy tools.
@0xabad1dea, yes, anyone buying crappy tools for big money falls under: 'a fool and his/her money are easily separated.'
@0xabad1dea This goes for Roller Derby too
on the one hand, it's possible to skate in imperfect equipment, and someone just picking up the sport doesn't have a lot of discretionary income, but boots that fit and wheels that are the right hardness for the floor you're learning on will remove a lot of the barriers
if you can't plow maybe the wheels really are to blame
I used to be all "I should be able to skate in anything," but having switched to a lighter plate really did level up my game
@0xabad1dea This confuses cause and effect. "The poor craftsperson blames their tools" means they don't admit their own incompetence. They would be an equally bad craftsperson even with good tools; that's what the proverb is saying - the tools are not the problem.
That a good craftsperson doesn't tolerate bad tools is a different thing. The good craftsperson will not do a bad job then blame the tool - the good craftsperson will not use the bad tool. But whether forced to use bad tools or not, the good craftsperson will take responsibility for the work. And may even be able to compensate with skill for the deficiencies of the tools.
So the saying is not nonsense at all, let alone "complete nonsense".
@0xabad1dea I think "blame" is doing all the lifting here. If you're building something and your tools aren't up to the task, then fix/improve/replace/etc them! Or if that's impractical for time reasons, own the result as the right tradeoff given the constraints. I urgently needed to open a can and had only a screwdriver-doable but nasty, the result was hacky, and I called it "best I could do under the circumstances".
Dropping verifiable facts @0xabad1dea
It's not long after you realize the above before the next epiphany hits you:
That shitty manager who doesn't understand your work flow and can't budget his time much less yours? He was put there on purpose. Not because he was supposed to be good but wasn't, rather he's there because his incompatancy is the seal of his loyalty to management.
Because he sucks he will never be an ally of the worker who's talents are being extracted. He exists in no-mans land, constantly under-estimating what's capable and being forced to excuse his purpose because he doesn't understand it either.
@0xabad1dea a workman will complain about their tools when they are not fit for purpose. the master will complain that you are not using the tools correctly. that the tools you want to use are wrong, you should be using these tools. your master will complain that you are costing too much, there is no money to pay you after buying all these tools.
@0xabad1dea One of the only B-school dictums I've ever agreed with is: "A's hire A's. B's hire C's." Which I think explains why middle management, who either never knew how things were built, or has long forgotten, hires people who can't really do the work.
At my place, that's worsened by the policy that if an opening is left "too long", it gets closed because "it's obviously not needed." The idea that a manager would wait for a _qualified_ person is foreign to them.
@0xabad1dea
☝🏼 This isn't specifically about AI, but, it certainly applies.
I've been doing fiber arts for 30 years now, and the world of difference good needles, hooks, and fiber makes can not be overstated. It sounds snobbish when I tell newbies not to bother with acrylic yarns and temu tools, but there's no reason to put yourself through that as a beginner.
@0xabad1dea The point of the adage "It’s a poor worksman who blames his tools" is "if you screw up, it's your fault, not the tool's fault". And indeed, part of that is choosing the correct tool for the situation in the first place. It never meant "the tools are perfect and nothing is improvable about them."
“PHP, Gitlab, Node.js, the Number Four. Being a systems administrator today is more stressful than ever. Today, we’ll take a look at the best types of gin to help you cope with the horrors of the modern Internet, on this edition of ‘The Computer Chronicles.’”
i feel the root cause here is that computer security companies have eleventy billion trillion dollars to spend on vuln research, whilst your average open source project's security budget is ten bucks and a half-empty can of monster someone left in an office fridge
Nothing puts the lie to "PHP is irrelevant" like "good morning, 70% of the internet needs to be fixed ASAP".
@csilverman Just because something is relevant does not mean it is not dogshit. - Sun Tzu, probably
@sackofbones Yeah, I never really understood all the PHP hate. I'm not a software engineer, so I'm sure there are legitimate technical criticisms of it, but most of the anti-PHP shade sounded more like the usual tech-world factionalism than anything else.
(although I do understand if a lot of IT/SRE folks are not feeling so warm and fuzzy about PHP today)
They hate PHP because it got popular, so it's trendy to be a hater of popular things. Mind you, it's been over 20 years, you'd think they would have grown out of that. 🙄
@csilverman @sackofbones I think PHP does a good job.
With some of the larger systems, other languages (such as python) might have been better choices.
But everything starts with a quick PHP hack. Then another. Then another. And before you know it, you're staring at a solution that of it were designed from the ground up might have been better using another language.
That's my thought. It's like so many other things. A junior dev encounters the solution without understanding it snowballed. 🙃
@csilverman Dont remind me, had a shit day because of this. It prooves once again that Express.js is far superiour.
@csilverman
PHP community
https://github.com/search?q=language%3APHP&type=repositories
at github.com has approximately same dimension as C# community
https://github.com/search?q=language%3AC%23&type=repositories
Most PHP projects are mostley web-projects hosted on apache2 with mod_php on linux machines.libapache2-mod-php8.5 libapache2-mod-php
@csilverman @bathtub_jen sure but it’s the 70% of the internet that was already botnets, cryptominers, and content farms
@csilverman There's another favorite of mine with the same argument: No one uses Linux.
I look at their smug face and their Windows/Mac system, before turning to the WiFi APs, routers and basically every other embedded thing they have in their house not to talk about them probably running the Linux kernel in their Android phone.
@apzpins Also, considering the increasingly hostile tendencies of Microsoft and Apple—ads, subscriptions, lock-in, bad/malicious UX around every corner—Linux honestly doesn't sound so bad.
Everyone loves to joke about the year of Linux on the desktop, but I could see it now more than ever.
it’s advised that all system administrators should turn off all their systems
you’re free now
solving my infosec problems by rewriting my site to not use TLS/HTTPS and just some perl scripts under cgi-bin
actually I have been working towards setting up a dial-in BBS (over real phone lines)
NO PRIME NUMBERS OR PHP NEEDED
@foone Tom7 has a nice video about how to do maliciously compliant TLS. "Nobody can force me to have a secure website!"
So, no matter how bad the PHP fallout proves to be, I have to concede that they *have* cleaned up their act quite a bit in recent years and these sorts of bugs out of PHP are much, much rarer than they used to be
Did you know that, when I was a fiery young programmer in my 20s, I ran a hate blog dedicated to the PHP manual and how bad, unreliable, and unhelpful it was? Here are some highlights:
Special snowflake not-actually-a-function isset() https://phpmanualmasterpieces.tumblr.com/post/52082199266/unsettling
The notorious strcmp() footgun https://phpmanualmasterpieces.tumblr.com/post/44634822304/i-am-so-comically-angry-right-now
When 1 equals 4096 https://phpmanualmasterpieces.tumblr.com/post/33023415508/when-does-one-byte-equal-four-kilobytes
PBKDF API designed to trip you up https://phpmanualmasterpieces.tumblr.com/post/66426423275/i-cant-spell-pbkdf
And, my favorite, a review of the complete original PHP 2.0 manual from the late 90s: https://phpmanualmasterpieces.tumblr.com/post/65544023819/php-20-a-review-in-retrospect
(The picture of Espurr in that post links to a domain that used to play the Lavender Town theme. Please put on Lavender Town yourself for full effect)
All these posts are 12 to 15 years old and do not necessarily reflect the current state of either the documentation or the code. Gods, I hope they don't.
anyway I just learned that the Dutch government service websites are implemented in PHP because a national news alert has gone out that they're shut down for the day due to reasons
@maltita I don't consider this a Picard Facepalm – modern PHP is not as insane a pick as old PHP for something so important, and given that we know a really bad bug is dropping, shutting down a few hours ahead of time is the correct call
@0xabad1dea ah no I think shutting down is the best call here, the facepaml was because the reach of the vulnerability that even that has to shut down
and for the record, I am not Eevee of "fractal of bad design" fame; I am sure people have mixed up me and @eevee before. Understandable, we're both cute girls who had a Passionate PHP Hater phase in our distant youths. But I'm a knockoff vocaloid and she's a pokemon. Completely different!
This was eevee's original extremely famous blog post: https://eev.ee/blog/2012/04/09/php-a-fractal-of-bad-design/ which also largely does not apply to PHP As She Is Meant To Be Spoke in 2026, but you can use it as a guide for how not to design a language or other complex software system.
@0xabad1dea @eevee I guess I have to thank you two for nudging me to write https://ninad.pundaliks.in/blog/2013/11/so-long-php/ (and also break off of php) then!
I do agree that a bunch of things have improved since then, whether it's in the main language line or the hack lang/hhvm line
@0xabad1dea They don't and if you find anything like that nowadays, just submit a PR to fix it as the docs are maintained on GitHub. PHP src as well for that matter.
Other than that, hey, security issues happen. It's how a project responds to them that matters and PHP is doing a quick, but also a very responsible co-ordinated release together with distros etc, so I think that says a lot.
Can't say for sure whether the funding via @thephpf helped in this case, but fund them anyway!
@0xabad1dea Indeed less of the facepalms we saw in the first 15 years of the 2000s.
But there are still some gems. Like rand()
> **Caution**
> This function does not generate cryptographically secure values, and *must not* be used for cryptographic purposes, or purposes that require returned values to be unguessable.
@berkes I cannot believe they STILL haven't put a strong rng by default behind rand()
@0xabad1dea @berkes huh, I thought "fast/insecure PRNG" was the norm across languages, at least libc seems to be in that camp according to a quick research (no I'm not using AI overview)
@0xabad1dea @berkes I mean, sure, I just didn't feel like PHP was *singularly bad* in that regard, more like "a widespread if questionable pattern that never got challenged". but maybe I'm misremembering things.
@0xabad1dea I will never forget PHP is physically hurting me https://phpmanualmasterpieces.tumblr.com/post/70257636397/im-crying-literally-crying-actual-tears-in-my
poll: if you use Git, do you use a terminal text editor to edit your commit messages? (or other things that Git asks you to edit like interactive rebases etc)
(you can pick more than one)
| yes, I use a terminal text editor: | 1182 |
| no, I use a GUI text editor: | 196 |
| no, I use a Git GUI/IDE integration/Magit/etc: | 365 |
| other: | 74 |
@b0rk _nearly_ got to tick all the boxes! I use emacs, but depending on the circumstances, it might be an emacs launched specially when I run 'git commit' from the shell prompt, or I may be running Magit in an emacs I had already. In either case the emacs may be GUI or tty-only, depending on whether I'm doing it at the other end of an ssh connection.
Alas, I couldn't think of any excuse to tick the 'other' box too :-)
(I do have a completely daft trick where I set VISUAL="cp file.txt", causing git to use the contents of that pre-prepared file instead of spawning an editor. But I only use that for prewritten 'git rebase -i' lists. For commit messages, there's no need: 'git commit' has a perfectly good -F option.)
@simontatham @b0rk other: if it’s small, I’ll just do commit -m “Add one line for insert standard reason”
@utterlymundane @b0rk oh, well, yes, for xkcd.com/1296 style commit messages that you're going to come back and write up more sensibly later, -m is good enough. I assumed those were out of scope for this poll!
I suppose a good example of "other" might be writing a description for a PR or MR on a git forge website, which is later turned into a commit message by some squash-and-merge workflow, discarding the messages from the actual commits you uploaded?
@simontatham @utterlymundane @b0rk it doesn't have to be too sinful, if you commit a lot on a branch and squash before or during merge.
Can end up like neat bullet points. In theory.
That's horrible (complement).
(I'd be *way* too nervous to do that, and would just have the editor insert the prewritten text, though.)
@suetanvil @b0rk the usual reason I'm providing a prewritten 'git rebase -i' list in the first place is so I can try it over and over again until I get it right. For the same reason, I usually also make a separate clone of the git repo to do it in, so that I can mess up the first 10 attempts without doing any permanent damage!
@simontatham @suetanvil @b0rk When I'm going to do a rebase that I'm afraid I might mess up, I start with `git checkout -b rb`, and rebase that instead. Then when I'm happy with `rb` I reset the real ref to the same place. If I'm unhappy I delete `rb` and nobody is the wiser.
Why would you want to use a fresh repo?
@mjd @suetanvil @b0rk in more detail, the reason I've used this workflow in the past is when preparing a release branch of PuTTY, following on from a previous release branch but cherry-picking a subset of changes from more recent trunk development.
I go through and make a list of the trunk changes I think deserve to be on the release branch; cherry-pick them, test, make sure it all works; but that's a first draft, and then I consult with other team members to see if they have anything to add/remove or have opinions on the borderline cases. Then I maybe edit my list of cherry-picks and build a second-draft version of the release branch. That way the branch doesn't end up with "apply this change" / "revert it 2 weeks later" clutter.
The list of cherry-picks is nicest to keep in the form of a 'git rebase -i' todo list, rather than a plain shell script full of 'git cherry-pick' commands, because sometimes there's a conflict when cherry-picking a trunk change, and I prefer the rebase -i system of pausing, letting me fix it, and continuing.
So I fix the conflict, and in the next version of the todo file, I replace 'cherry-pick -x foo' with 'pick [new version of foo I just made]', so that the already-adapted version of that commit is the one that gets applied the next time I rebuild the draft release branch. Kind of like 'git rerere' except that I do it explicitly and state exactly _what_ saved conflict resolution I want to use, and when.
The part about picking commits from an earlier draft branch depends on those commits not having been garbage-collected since I last ran the script. So I do all of this in a separate clone of the repo from the one where I'm doing unrelated trunk development.
Also, the full branch rebuilding script includes commands to switch branch, delete branch, recreate branch etc. Another reason to keep it far away from unrelated work.
@simontatham @mjd @suetanvil @b0rk do you version your rebase files? no need to answer
this is amazing but also terrifying
@simontatham @b0rk I have sometimes done GIT_EDITOR=cat for rebases, when I just want an automatic fixup. (Less necessary now, as git is getting more tools for this.)
I know it’s incredibly bad but the whole “we used a private key that was just 4” thing has weirdly cheered me up. It’s just nice to see regular human stupidity rather than the increasing amount of over-engineered automated stupidity
p » 🌐
@p@hj.9fs.net
https://www.redbubble.com/shop/ap/184910608
commissioned by @exa@mastodon.online
pls buy something, i asked her out and i need money for the date now.
@p NELEROVSP
p » 🔓
@p@hj.9fs.net
CC: @jn@boopsnoot.de
p » 🔓
@p@hj.9fs.net
p » 🔓
@p@hj.9fs.net
p » 🔓
@p@hj.9fs.net
p » 🔓
@p@hj.9fs.net
Fedi, what's your favourite games that can be played with just your non dominant hand? Obviously visual novels, but I want something with more direct control this time
The reason is: yesterday I've felt sick after an MRI, and late in the evening fell from the stairs, fucking up my dominant hand a fair bit. It's unlikely to be a fracture but I am still waiting to be seen by a doctor
Edit: it was a fracture. Yikes
Oh no! 🫂
Hope it all turns out OK and your hand feels better soon.
Whatever it is, give yourself and your hand time to rest and heal up. Really, please do.
Use fingerless gloves to keep your hand warm (if you can) Maybe not use a mouse rather a trackball or such (or best of all; rest!) Also, don't overuse your non-dominant hand!
@nina_kali_nina some of the "Game And Watch Gallery" games only use two buttons. if you can get the first two in the series as roms you can probably set them up with a keyboard scheme that plays with just one hand
@nina_kali_nina games like older turn based RPGs might also work well controlled similarly
@aeva FF6 with WASD controls, huh, legit
@nina_kali_nina yeah that would be a good one. earthbound would be another. chrono trigger might be fine as long as you set it to "wait" and not "active"
@nina_kali_nina @aeva Not just RPGs!
Any management sim or wargame with a console port should be fine with WASD plus Q and E and maybe shift or space. Some old shmup with autofire added as long as autofire doesn't break the gameplay. There's titles with default autofire.
Think Afterburner on MegaDrive. You need one button for missiles and only rarely you need to accelerate or decelerate. The vulcan fires all the time anyway.
@nina_kali_nina I think I pretty much never use the keyboard for Two Point games. It does require a lot of mousing for the camera controls so it depends on how comfortable you are with your non-dominant hand. They’re pretty hilarious games though.
I hope your hand recovers soon!
@nina_kali_nina the shooty minigame on the Wii pack-in disc (Wii play?), there's probably a few good ones here. The one where you rotate Miis to pop their bubble is fun too.
@nina_kali_nina super monkey ball GameCube, u only need control one analog stick
i played it a lot when my tendonitis was particularly terrible as could only use one arm also when i broke my arm lol
@nina_kali_nina A day when my arthrosis was bad in my left thumb, I remapped forward and backwards in Minecraft to my gaming mouse. It kinda worked.
@nina_kali_nina Dorfromantik comes to mind, you can play it with one hand, placement is really simple so you don't need to be precise about it and there's no time pressure of any kind in doing it. Bonus points for being a game where you can jump in and out at any time.
@nina_kali_nina I'd say most retro or arcade-ish games where you find a way of remapping buttons. For instance, you could play most Gameboy games by mapping A and B to L1 and L2 on a Gamepad. Start and Select might be harder, but maybe you can map stick and arrows independently or use your nose in the rare cases where you need them.
@nina_kali_nina When I had a really bad outbreak of poison ivy on my dominant hand as a kid, I had to have it wrapped to the point it was basically just a flipper. I found most N64 games relatively easy to play with my off-hand, using its oddly-shaped controller, since you rarely need to be able to use *all* the face buttons.
@nina_kali_nina did you tried slay the princess? Maybe some turn base games (I'm thinking strategy) should be possible to play with one hand
@nina_kali_nina
Crypt of the Necrodancer's a pretty great rythym roguelite. Only need the arrow keys to play it
Fairly sure about these
Stone simulator
Summer House
Sigils of Elohim (not sure if still obtainable)
Townscaper
Urbo
Dorf Romantik
Unpacking
Peggle
Bridge constructor
Splice
Osmos
Sam and Max (any single one)
Not sure about these
Flower
Retrowave
You can also check if you can rebind some of the keys to a more usable set for you right now. Also don't forget you can use the numeric keypad as a mouse (accessibility)
@nina_kali_nina How well can you mouse with your off hand?
Also be REALLY careful with this: last time I got RSI in my right hand, I switched to doing everything with my left and got it in both in under TWO DAYS. Turns out you do NOT have the same time in your non-dominant hand.
On the plus side, I learned to play Ogre Battle 64 with my feet and an arcade pad.
@nina_kali_nina Anyway, I have a list due to fucking up my right hand a bunch of times, but I'm also pretty good with my left hand as a result, so YMMV on how frustrating these are.
Pretty much any turn based game: I like Civilization 4, but the whole series should work. Also Age of Wonder 1 & 2 with Simultaneous Turns turned off, and Battle for Wesnoth.
@nina_kali_nina You CAN do older JRPGs (or old style ones like Dragon Quest) but it's a pain moving your hand move to input in the controller, and see above point about being very careful not to do too much with your off-hand. Smaller controllers like the SNES you can lay flat on a desk help with this
@Canageek I'm currently playing Dragon Quest 1, with ganepad remapped for the left hand only . It's very comfy
@nina_kali_nina Nice! I beat that back on Game Boy a very long time ago. I can see that being an excellent choice
@nina_kali_nina Oof, hope you recover quickly.
My mind goes immediately to classic arcade games where the controls are limited and an emulator can easily remap them. Pac-Man, Frogger, Q*Bert, most driving games, shooters to a limited extent (Space Invaders is probably doable, Galaga less so).
@nina_kali_nina
Can recommend "Into the Breach". It was named GOTY a couple of times. I am many hundred hours in.
"Desktop Dungeons" is also quite entertaining.
More relaxed still: "Monument Valley" series.
Edit: somehow overread the "direct controls". Sry. These aren't that.
Somehow the new #design of #mastodon made the home feed much less readable to me. Is it the text being more horizontally squashed because the column is narrower? Or that the avatars now hog an entire column? Or that the #hashtags take more space and attention now that they are visual elements instead of slightly different text? I've not used any apps to read mastodon because I was content with readability of the website feed, and now I'm kinda at a loss as to wtf I'm supposed to do with this =/
@khobochka I use Elk btw
@rene This looks nice. Sure, there are client apps that look cleaner and can probably be easily customized, I was just a bit upset about losing the convenience of simply using the browser
RE: https://indieweb.social/@jaredwhite/117474548425817562
bracketing copyright stuff, where i think i’m just less of a libertarian -- which, fair enough, i guess -- one disagreement i have here (besides the framing piece) is that i am sick of being asked to factor what a given technology *might* do in the future into my present-day politics. the actually-existing use cases cited here strike me as either uninteresting (dishwasher manual summary) or misleading (even “just checking for typos” can actually alter semantic content)
I disagree with Cory's framing of all of this. 🤷🏻♂️
He's right that AI is just more software, nothing special. He's wrong that because software exists we can use it. Just because there's a machine where you can prompt a feature and it "writes" a piece of software doesn't mean one *should* do so. And so on and so forth.
So yes, I am anti-AI in all the ways he thinks are "weird." Sorry.
https://locusmag.com/feature/commentary-cory-doctorow-technopolitics/
@theodoraward This has always been the key to tech evangelism: Focusing on potential, especially when there's no real current value. It's worked for nearly 50 years; now it's not and so the evangelists have largely had to resort to gaslighting to avoid admitting that maybe, just maybe, some tech is actually bad and has no place in a functioning society.